Monday, April 18, 2005

anti-Japan demonstrations

 
i find it suspicious and a bit suprised that spontaneous demonstrations have occured in China involving thousands of people, given the Communist Party's consistent record of quelling protests. i feel its naive to say that this is a dispute about reconciling historical acts. it happened almost 70 years ago and Japan has apologised 21 one times apparently (albiet sanitised by ultranational Japanese), and I won't be suprised if they have gone unacknowledged. also, history books are almost always skewed in favour of portraying the existing government in a good light - you don't see China publicising its invasion of Tibet nor is it widely known in America that historical hero Columbus and his crew committed nothing short of genocide of native Americans.

China's benefit is two-fold. Chinese people are not known to be patriotic (only until recently, as people start to become proud of her economic achievements, but much less the case in the pre-Deng era). if anti-Japanese sentiment can be used to unite the Chinese people to back the government (and its political agenda), so much the better.

secondly (and probably why such protests have been timed now), it also gives China public support and thus extra leverage and media coverage over issues such as the contended oil fields and Japan's aspirations for a seat on the UN permanent security council. so, setting aside other dimensions, if Japan hypothetically did apologise in full (wouldn't count on it - I believe Japan would think that China is being unreasonable and manipulative), would this not give Japan the upper hand?

in the long term, it is not hard to see a power struggle between the two increasingly entangled nations. China is becoming more and more bold, with its increasing economic clout in the region, and is determined to use this to influence Japan. nonetheless, China would be unwise to let this jeapordise the commercial interdependence between the two nations...

my first blog on politics! it might sound like i regurgitated some of it, but i'm just taking the views of others and expanding on it. an interesting topic... with many more interesting views here.

 


2 Comments:

At Mon Apr 18, 01:08:00 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi there JJ, it's Geoff (mathmo, left Cam). I started reading your blog recently, and just wanted to express my agreement with this post! Keep up the great work.

 
At Wed Apr 27, 03:36:00 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I feel it's sadly about power struggles in an international arena now.

Besides, history is never without its bias. Whether you read it on the news or from a historical text, you cannot completely remove the bias, and therefore forming a strong opinion based on such ambiguous information is touchy business. And you also get ignorant citizens/politicians who teach their presuming views and e.g. come up with irrational claims like the past was fabricated, one never apologises, etc. These do no good when you want to find the truth of the matter.

I think, or rather I hope, that in actual fact, most Japanese realise the horrors of their country's past. And that most Chinese keep the past in their memories and remember them, but are ready to move on.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home